Served with Homefries, Hashbrowns & Toast
Thick-cut bacon, crisp iceberg lettuce, sliced ripe tomatoes, and homemade aioli on sourdough toast. Like the 1935 Art Deco building Atlantic Bagels calls home, a classic for a reason.
Hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh all day from the best ingredients. Twelve of your choice, and a thirteenth on the house so you have something nice to nosh on.
Hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh all day from the best ingredients. Six of your choice, and a seventh on the house just to be nice.
Handrolled & Baked Fresh All Day
Handrolled & Baked Fresh All Day
Handrolled & Baked Fresh All Day
Handrolled & Baked Fresh All Day
Handrolled & Baked Fresh All Day
Handrolled & Baked Fresh All Day
Handrolled & Baked Fresh All Day
Handrolled & Baked Fresh All Day
Handrolled & Baked Fresh All Day
Handrolled & Baked Fresh All Day
A 100-year-old Carroll Gardens tradition-- famous Italian-American specialty, LARD BREAD-- now made into one of the most delicious bagels you've ever tried. Packed with salami and black pepper, plus a bit of provelone, there's nothing more delicious. Try to eat just one!
Handrolled & Baked Fresh All Day
Rye flour and caraway seeds both inside and out. Jewish rye bread as a bagel, it gets no better.
Our delicious plain bagel flattened out before being baked, making for more crusty surface area and less doughy bread on the inside. A customer favorite.
Our delicious whole wheat bagel flattened out before being baked, making for more crusty surface area and less doughy bread on the inside.
Our delicious poppy bagel flattened out before being baked, making for more crust, more seeds, and less doughy bread on the inside. A customer favorite.
Our delicious whole-wheat-everything bagel flattened out before being baked, making for more crusty surface area, more flavorful seeds and spices, and less doughy bread on the inside. Big customer favorite!
These are made off-site in a certified gluten-free bakery. Any bagels cut, toasted, or otherwise altered at our shop do risk exposure to other items that contain gluten.
Mixed Fresh Daily
Mixed fresh daily from top-quality Philadelphia cream cheese and chopped fresh scallions.
Mixed Fresh Daily
Mixed Fresh Daily
Mixed Fresh Daily
Mixed Fresh Daily
Mixed Fresh Daily
Mixed Fresh Daily
Mixed Fresh Daily
Mixed Fresh Daily
Mixed Fresh Daily
Albacore tuna mixed with mayonnaise, celery, capers, red onion, and fresh herbs. A customer favorite.
Top quality smoked whitefish mixed with a little mayonnaise and a nice grind of black pepper. Delicious on a bagel, or almost anything else.
The very best smoked nova lox in NYC, hand-sliced, carefully packed, and ready to eat on bagels, eggs, or straight out of the package.
Juicy fresh blueberries and a touch of blueberry preserves mixed into luscious, top-quality cream cheese. One of the tastiest, most beautiful spreads ever. Amazing on an egg bagel.
So good, even grown-ups can't stop eating it! Rainbow sprinkles and vanilla mixed into fresh, top-quality cream cheese. A not-too-sweet but oh-so-satisfying treat that brings out the kid in anyone.
Baked fresh daily, our pure butter croissants are perfect on their own or as a sandwich. Bon appetite!
Baked fresh every day, our all-butter croissant filled with bittersweet chocolate. Huge favorite for breakfast, a snack, or dessert anytime.
Our flaky all-butter croissant, baked fresh daily, filled with almond paste and covered in sliced almonds. Incomparably delicious.
Our all-butter croissant dough, formed into a scrumptious danish, filled with sweetened cream cheese, and sprinkled with a few almond slices before being baked to perfection. Unbeatable for breakfast, a snack, or a dessert anytime.
Baked Fresh Daily
Baked in-house every day, our jumbo lemon-poppy muffin is superb for breakfast, as a snack, or for dessert any time of the day.
Baked in-house every day, our jumbo chocolate chip muffin is superb for breakfast or as a snack or dessert any time of the day.
Baked Fresh Daily
Baked Fresh Daily
Baked in-house every day, our jumbo banana-walnut muffin is superb for breakfast, as a snack, or for dessert any time of the day.
Organic chia seeds with coconut and almond milk, honey, mango, and blueberries. An in-store favorite.
Your favorite and ours, the NYC classic BEC. Exactly how you want it.
A juicy, flavorful homemade sausage patty, melting American cheese, and two scrambled eggs on your choice of bagel, roll, or bread.
On Bagel, Bialy, Roll, Wrap, or Toast (White, Wheat, Rye)
Served cooked however you like them, with homefries, and a bagel or toast of your choice.
Served with Homefries, Hashbrowns & Toast
Served with Homefries, Hashbrowns & Toast
Served with Homefries, Hashbrowns & Toast
Brooklyn-smoked Nova Lox, scallion cream cheese, sliced tomatoes and red onion, plus capers. On an everything bagel, or bagel of choice.
Hebrew National kosher beef salami, grainy mustard, and love on a caraway-rye bagel (as a default, or your bagel of choice.)
Tuna in Olive Oil, Artichoke Hearts, Olive Tapenade, and Arugula on a toasted Bialy.
Sliced roasted turkey breast, muenster cheese, avocado, tomato, kale salad, and herbed aoili on a fennel-raisin
Hearts of romaine, marinated and grilled chicken breast, and crunchy croutons tossed with homemade Caesar dressing and rolled up in a large whole wheat wrap.
Hummus, avocado, tomato, red onion, and arugula on a whole wheat everything bagel.
Black Forest Ham, Quince Jam, Emmenthaler on Pumpernickle.
Hand-formed fresh 100% Beef patty from Atlantic Avenue's famous Dellapietra's, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles, special sauce on a sesame seed bun from Court Street's 100-year-old Caputo's Bakery.
Juicy, marinated chicken, crispy on the outside, with American cheese, coleslaw, pickles, and house sauce on a brioche bun
Roast Chicken, Provolone, Pepperoncini, Arugula, and Balsamico on our soon-to-be-famous Lard Bread Bagel.
Homemade albacore tuna salad with capers and melted cheddar on griddle-toasted whole grain bread.
Thick-cut bacon, crisp iceberg lettuce, sliced ripe tomatoes, and homemade aioli on sourdough toast. Like the 1935 Art Deco building Atlantic Bagels calls home, a classic for a reason.
Three cheeses melted to perfection on the griddle on buttered whole grain bread. What could be better?
Homemade chicken soup from scratch, with pulled chicken breast, carrots, celery. And love, just like Grandma's.
Homemade from scratch from oven-roasted Roma tomatoes and a touch of thyme. Served with bagel chips.
Kale, shaved brussels sprouts, parmesean cheese, pepitas, and a homemade Caesar dressing. Add grilled chicken or salmon for extra protein.
Chickpeas, cherry tomatoes, kalamata olives, cucumbers, za'atar, and extra virgin olive oil. Delicious, high-protein, vegetarian, and satisfying on its own or over a green salad.
16oz of our perfectly balanced coffee, always freshly brewed with your choice of milks and/or sweeteners.
Freshly ground and expertly pulled espresso with steamed milk of your choice. More milk and less foam than a cappuccino.
Rich, delicious hot cocoa made with your choice of steamed milk or non-dairy milk options.
A leading Brooklyn restaurant on Grubhub